| Name | MVP Years | College |
|---|---|---|
| Michael Wang | 2016-2024 | MIT |
| Wesley Marville | 2023-2024 | Queens |
| Eli Turner | 2017-2024 | Wentworth |
| Aidan Cunningham | 2021-2024 | Wittenberg |
| Zachary Septoff | 2023-2024 | Randolph College |
| Meledje M'baye | 2021-2023 | Marymount |
| Dylan Mulvaney1 | 2019-2022 | Springfield |
| Corwin Trouteaud | 2017-2022 | Stevenson |
| Andrew Ahn | 2015-2022 | Arcadia / Wentworth |
| Nathan Goh | 2015-2022 | Ball State |
| Alex Lower | 2012-2014 | Cairn |
| William Schwob | 2011-2013 | Grand Canyon |
| Mark Shayka | 2010-2013 | Lees-McRae |
| Brandon Palmer | 2009-2013 | Loyola of Chicago / Marymount |
| Kyle Seeley | 2009-2013 | Juniata |
| Brendan Chang5 | 2008-2012 | MIT |
| Kevin Carter | 2008-2012 | Stevenson |
| Aaron Russell135 | 2007-2011 | Penn State |
| Cameron Palmer | 2007-2011 | Emmanuel |
| Dainis Berzins | 2007-2011 | Loyola of Chicago |
| Kyle Nail | 2007-2008 | Loyola of Chicago |
| David Lucas | 2006-2010 | George Mason |
| Jared Goldberg | 2006-2010 | Pacific/Grand Canyon |
| Peter Russell | 2006-2010 | Penn State |
| Matthew Schmidt | 2005-2008 | Juniata |
| Mikelis Berzins7 | 2005-2008 | Ohio State |
| Ryan Mullsteff | 2005-2008 | Loyola of Chicago |
| David Fitzgerald | 2005-2006 | Lindenwood |
| Andrew Cranford156 | 2004-2005 | Stevens Institute of Technology |
| Armando Rosso | 2003-2007 | Juniata |
| Eric Lucas | 2003-2007 | George Mason |
| Ryan McDowell | 2003-2005 | Stevenson |
| David Lloyd | 2002-2006 | Villajulie |
| John Kessenich | 2001-2005 | Vassar |
| William Price1457 | 2001-2005 | George Mason/Penn State |
| Matt Fritz | 2001-2004 | Juniata |
| Andrew Price | 2001-2002 | Penn State |
| Kris Berzins | 2000-2006 | Loyola of Chicago |
| Brett Hamilton | 1998-2001 | Ohio State |
| Victor Grafton | 1996-1998 | Trine |
| Andrew Hutchinson | 1994-1998 | Princeton |
| Nicholas Cheever57 | 1993-1998 | U of Arizona |
| Tony Mazzullo17 | 1992-1995 | Penn State |
| Mike Hung 7 | 1992-1994 | University of Maryland |
| John Hutchinson | 1989-1990 | Princeton |
| Bryant Lee17 | 1988-1993 | University of Maryland |
| Johnny Hsiung7 | 1988-1993 | University of Maryland |
| Bill Brooks | 1987-1988 | Park University |
| Scott Metcalf25 | 1985-1987 | George Mason |
| Tom Rice | 1985-1987 | George Mason |
1 All-American
2 Participated in 1987 and 1989 Olympic festivals and on USA National team roster
3 Current USA National team roster
4 Former USA National team roster
5 Played professionally overseas
6 National Player of the Year
7 National Champion
